Promoting Respect, Integrity and Dignity In Elders
A collaborative effort of Monroe County Office for the Aging, New York State Office for the Aging, Monroe County Protective Services for Adults, and LIFESPAN’s Elder Abuse Prevention Program.
Elder abuse occurs in every racial, social and economic group. It can happen in any village, town or city across the United States. Although many of its victims are older women, gender and chronological age alone do not totally define who will be abused or mistreated. However, in most cases, the perpetrator has gained the trust of the victim, therefore the perpetrator may be a friend, neighbor, someone they do business with, or even a family member.
“Elder abuse is a serious concern for Monroe County and for communities across the country. Through education and resources, such as this website, we can increase awareness and understanding of the issues facing our older residents. Identifying and preventing the mistreatment of mature adults is a community effort, and is the only sure way to safeguard our residents.”
—Maggie Brooks, County Executive
Protective Services for Adults
- LIFESPAN'S Elder Abuse Prevention Program
- Monroe County Protective Services For Adults
- Monroe County District Attorney’s Office
- New York State Office for the Aging Information Line
- New York State Domestic Violence Hotline
- New York State Crime Victims Hotline
- New York State Attorney General
585 546-7430 (Rochester)
Although each case involving elder abuse or neglect is unique, the following fictional scenarios demonstrate common themes which occur. The following three cases give an overview which will be useful to professionals, family or friends in identifying abuse or neglect.
Mrs. E. is a 75 year old woman who came to this country after surviving the concentration camps of World War II. Her husband and children are deceased and she lives with her only grandson, Tom. Tom has been in and out of drug and alcohol rehabilitation programs for the past five years and cannot keep a job. When he relapses, Tom becomes violent toward his grandmother, slapping and pushing her until she gives him the money he demands. Mrs. E. refuses to have Tom arrested, hoping that someday he will “get help” and again become the loving grandson she once knew.
Mr. and Mrs. V. have been married for 50 years and have four grown children. Despite Mr. V. being physically and verbally abusive to his wife their entire married life, she has stayed with him and has never told anyone of their problems. Over the last five years, Mrs. V. has become increasingly forgetful and confused which only infuriates her husband more. The doctor she now sees has determined that she has dementia and her condition will only worsen in the next few years. When asked about the bruises on her arms and back, Mr. V. tells the doctor that she has frequent falls. He then promptly finds a new physician for his wife; she has had four doctors in five years.
Mr. P. is an 85 year old man who receives care from his daughter after suffering a series of strokes. His daughter, Barb, and he have always had a stormy relationship and she blames him for putting her in the “nuthouse” when she was a teenager. Barb forbids outside help from assisting her father and none of his friends and neighbors have seen him outside his house for the past six months. They hear yelling and loud noises coming from the house but nobody wants to get involved. Barb is driving a new car and appears to be wearing very expensive jewelry during the brief visits she makes with her father.
Profile of a Typical Elder Abuse Victim
- socially isolated
- physically and/or cognitively impaired
- denies, or is reluctant to report, abuse
Profile of a Typical Abuser
- family member/caregiver
- drug/alcohol/mental health problem(s)
- controlling personality and/or ineffective coping skills
- under financial/emotional/marital stress
Elder abuse is a hidden problem which has only recently received national attention. New York State, in Chapter 395 of the Social Services Laws of 1995, has defined the categories of abuse as follows:
- Physical Abuse: The non-accidental use of force that results in bodily injury, pain or impairment, including but not limited to, being slapped, burned, cut, bruised or improperly physically restrained.
- Financial/Material Exploitation: The improper use of an adult’s funds, property or resources by another individual, including but not limited to, fraud, false pretenses, embezzlement, conspiracy, forgery, falsifying records, coerced property transfers or denial of access to assets.
- Active Neglect: The willful failure by the caregiver to fulfill the care-taking functions and responsibilities assumed by the caregiver, including abandonment, willful deprivation of food, water, heat, clean clothing and bedding, eyeglasses or dentures, or health-related services.
- Sexual Abuse: Non-consensual sexual contact of any kind, including but not limited to, forcing sexual contact or forcing sex with a third party.
- Passive Neglect: The non-willful failure of the caregiver to fulfill care-taking functions and responsibilities ... because of inadequate caregiver knowledge, infirmity, or disputing the value of prescribed services.
The following lists possible family and/or individual symptoms of elder abuse. Each indicator, by itself, may not signal an abusive situation. There are other factors which must be considered before reaching such a conclusion.
- Physical Abuse: Unexplained bruises, falls, fractures, grip marks, pain, swelling or welts.
- Neglect: Malnourishment, bedsores, soiled clothes, over sedation, lack of medical attention or equipment despite available funds, tied to chair or bed.
- Emotional/Verbal Abuse: Depressed, hopeless, appears shamed, withdrawn, passive, loss of self-determination, invalid guilt, threatened, called names, fearful.
- Financial Exploitation: Illegal use of elders’ money/possessions/resources for others’ gain. Examples: elder has no money for food/clothes; is victimized by con artists; has a caregiver who is totally financially dependent upon them; is forced to sign over control/power of attorney; and has unexplained bills and charge card or banking activity.
The National Center on Elder Abuse recently published the results of the first, comprehensive national incidence study, covering the year 1996. According to this study, approximately 450,000 elderly persons in domestic settings were abused and/or neglected during 1996. Additionally, the study determined that:
- Female elders are abused at a higher rate than males, after accounting for their larger proportion in the aging population.
- Our oldest elders (age 80+) are abused and neglected at two to three times their proportion of the elderly population.
- In almost 90% of the elder abuse and neglect incidents with a known perpetrator, the perpetrator is a family member, with two-thirds being adult children or spouses.
- Almost half of substantiated abused and neglected elderly were not physically able to care for themselves.
- The most frequent reporters were family members (20%), followed by hospitals, police and in-home providers.
- The most common types of elder abuse by perpetrators were: neglect, emotional/psychological, financial/material exploitation, and physical abuse.
Q. I suspect an elderly person may be the victim of elder abuse. What should I do?
Get as much information as possible about the signs of elder abuse and compare this with the situation you are observing. Ask questions of the alleged victim, in a respectful, but direct manner. It is recommended, and may be necessary, to interview the older person privately, without the alleged perpetrator present.
Q. Where can I obtain information on elder abuse?
In New York State, contact your local Office for the Aging and/or Adult Protective Services. You can also find the listing in our website directory. For other areas in the United States, call the Eldercare Locator at 1-800-677-1116.
Q. If an elderly person is being abused, what choices does he or she have?
Unless a court has determined that s/he is lacking in capacity to make his/her own decisions, the person has the same rights as any adult to make choices about his/her living situation. These choices can range from taking action against the abuser to doing nothing and allowing the situation to continue. When the victim chooses to stay in the abusive relationship, it is often the most difficult choice for the family, friends and service providers to understand. Counseling, in-home services, other living arrangements and adult day programs are some other options which might improve the situation and reduce the risk of further abuse.
Q. Can't Adult Protective Services force a change in the situation?
Not if the victim has capacity and knows his/her options. Lack of capacity can only be determined by a medical evaluation and a ruling by the courts.
Adult Protective workers will interview the alleged victim and make an assessment of the situation. They will probably employ the least restrictive method of intervention to address the problem.
A medical evaluation to determine capacity should be as comprehensive as possible. Physical and cognitive abilities/disabilities should be evaluated, preferably by a doctor that has experience with older adults. The primary care physician may be willing to make a referral to a geriatric assessment clinic or a geriatric psychiatrist if cognitive (mental) functioning is suspected to be impaired. A written report of the findings should emphasize the level of incapacity or impaired judgment, and in which areas of functioning these impairments occur, e.g., ability to make financial decisions, live by themselves and understand health risks.
Q. What legal options exist for the victim?
There are several, depending on the circumstances and desire of the victim to choose one. In New York State, s/he may choose to get an Order of Protection judge will take into account the wishes of the victim when issuing an Order of Protection. This order may or may not include the expulsion of the perpetrator from the home. Another option, particularly in cases of physical abuse, is to call the police and have the perpetrator arrested under the state’s Domestic Violence Law. In cases of financial exploitation, there are several legal options available, such as guardianship, to stop the exploitation. Victims should contact their attorney, the local District Attorney’s Office or Adult Protective Services to see if criminal or civil charges can be pursued. If outside New York State, check with your local Adult Protective Services office.
Q. I know of an older woman who is being physically and financially abused. She doesn't want her substance-addicted grandson to go to jail, so the police are not called. All she keeps saying is can't you make him get help? What can I do?
Your options are limited. Even though you may want to act on an older person’s behalf, the victim must agree to take some action. You can call your local Office for the Aging or Adult Protective Services.
Your identity will be kept confidential. New York State’s Social Services Law 473-e provides this protection for those who call in a referral. However, the victim can get an order of protection (see previous question) and a determination will be made without incurring criminal sanctions. If the grandchild violates the order, he may go to jail for contempt of court.
Q. An elderly man has been caring for his wife for many years. I believe she has Alzheimer’s disease. He seems very stressed. Will he become abusive?
Not necessarily. Recent research is casting doubt on the long-held belief that the stress of care giving, by itself, will inevitably lead to abuse. Subjective factors such as a caregiver’s response to the situation, feelings of guilt, being constantly in demand or feeling out of control were more important. Of equal importance was the relationship between the caregiver and care receiver. If there has been a past history of poor relations, or the care receiver is perceived to be unappreciative or demanding, the risk for possible abuse increases (From The Mistreatment of Elderly People, London Sage Publications, 1993).
Try taking this brief elder abuse quiz. Answer either True or False (answers below).
- Forty-two states in the United States have a mandatory reporting law for elder abuse in the community.
- Adult Protective Services has the same legal powers to intervene as Child Protective Services.
- New York State has a mandatory reporting law for elder abuse which covers all professionals who deal with seniors in the community.
- Physical abuse is the most prevalent form of elder abuse.
- Slapping, choking or pushing can be considered harassment rather than an assault.
- Most care giving in our country is performed by nursing agencies in the client’s home.
- A Power of Attorney (attorney in fact) is limited to making financial decisions and cannot be used to make health care decisions, such as nursing home placement.
- The federal government established nationwide definitions, detailed criteria and standards for elder abuse in the Older Americans Act.
- Most victims of elder abuse are women over the age of 80.
- Spouses are the most frequent abusers of the elderly.
- True. The remaining eight states rely on voluntary reporting of elder abuse by professionals.
- False. Adults have a right to remain in an abusive situation if they choose.
- False. Although New York State law does not mandate reporting, many professional organizations expect their members to report such cases.
- False. Neglect is the most common form of elder abuse.
- True. if visible signs are not present or detected.
- False. Most care giving (more than 90%) is provided by family members.
- True. In New York State, a Power of Attorney is necessary to make financial decisions for another person. A Health Care Proxy is needed to make health care decisions on behalf of an incapacitated person.
- False. No national standards exist; policy and definitions are developed on a state-by-state basis.
- True. The 1998 National Incidence Study determined that the oldest old (i.e., over age 80) woman is at the highest risk of being victimized by elder abuse.
- False. Adult children are the most frequent perpetrators.
Orders of Protection in New York State
A person is eligible to go to Family Court for an Order when:
- they are married to an abuser
- they were formerly married to an abuser
- they have a child in common with an abuser
- they are related by blood or marriage to an abuser
Before an Order can be obtained in Town Court, a criminal charge must have been filed and signed by an officer or the victim.
Mandatory Domestic Violence Arrests
Police must arrest when:
- a felony, other than grand larceny crimes, has been committed against a member of the same family or household
- there is violation of the stay away provision of a duly served Order of Protection, or when the perpetrator was present when such Order of Protection was issued by a judge
- a family offense is committed in violation of an Order of Protection
Family offenses include:
- harassment (first and second degree)
- aggravated harassment
- disorderly conduct
- reckless endangerment (first and second degree)
- menacing (second degree—violation of stay away provision)
- menacing (first degree)
- assault (second and third degree)
A misdemeanor constituting a family offense is committed against another family or household member, unless the victim requests otherwise. However, the officer shall not ask the victim whether s/he seeks the arrest of the perpetrator. Even if the victim requests no arrest, the officer can use his/her own discretion as to whether an arrest should be made.
Both courts can order:
- the abusive behavior to stop (no offensive contact order)
- the abuser to have no contact with the victim (stay away order)
- the abuser to leave the residence (vacate)